Car manufacturers have been copying each other's designs for ages. This is not new. Here I present my case where a company shamelessly copies another. Toyota vs. Mazda. The car in question: The 2011 Corolla. For as long as anyone can remember, Toyota has been known for their unoffensive design strategy. Make something mainstream, otherwise known as boring.
I think the design was poorly implemented, but the vehicle was still successful. Toyota quickly made modifications for 2011 to give the Corolla a sportier look. This is where Mazda comes in with the 2003 Mazda 6. This shows how far behind Toyota was with their 9th generation. Typical for a mid-cycle upgrade, Toyota kept the main structure and interior, only updating a little of the front fascia (headlights and grill) and the back end (taillights and bumper).
Above: 2011 Toyota Corolla and 2003 Mazda 6
As you can see, the headlights were mildly upgraded to give a slimmer appearance, similar to the Mazda. The most apparent copy was adding a couple bars across the grill to imitate the 6's distinctive look. They also opened the lower grill more to give it a sportier feel, and added a bar across the side of the vehicle to minimize door dings, both found on the Mazda.
Above: 2011 Toyota Corolla and 2003 Mazda 6
In the back, the most prominent change in the Corolla is the taillights. Although they are not an exact copy, they give a similar impression as the 6 by adding silver accents to the middle. The taillights were also slimmed to provide a more uniform shape, like the Mazda. The lower reflectors on the bumper even got slimmed down similar to the 6.
Conclusion: I believe that Toyota shamelessly copied attributes of the 2003 Mazda 6 to update the poorly envisioned 2003 Toyota Corolla. I don't see anything wrong with manufacturers learning from one another, but not in a fashion like this. I believe automotive design to be a form of art, and therefore should not be copied. Flattery can be great, but not for merely increasing sales. Toyota is now creating their own distinctive, although confusing, design. I look forward to what they produce. Hopefully something better looking than the Mirai.
This is just my opinion, but I will let you be the judge.
Photo Credits
2003 Corolla: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toyota_Corolla_(E120)#/media/File:2003-2004_Toyota_Corolla_CE.jpg
2009 Corolla front: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toyota_Corolla_(E140)#/media/File:09_Toyota_Corolla.jpg
2009 Corolla back: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toyota_Corolla_(E140)#/media/File:2007-2010_Toyota_Corolla_(ZRE152R)_Ascent_sedan_01.jpg
2011 Corolla front: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toyota_Corolla_(E140)#/media/File:2011_Toyota_Corolla_Altis_1.8E_in_Puchong,_Malaysia_(01).jpg
2003 6 front: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mazda6#/media/File:2005-2007_Mazda_6_(GG_Series_2)_Luxury_Sports_hatchback_(2011-01-13).jpg
2011 Corolla back: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toyota_Corolla_(E140)#/media/File:2011_Toyota_Corolla_Altis_1.8E_in_Puchong,_Malaysia_(02).jpg
2003 6 back: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mazda6#/media/File:2006_Mazda6_(GG_Series_2)_MZR-CD_hatchback_(2015-08-07)_02.jpg
No comments:
Post a Comment